Stage 1 - Introduction: presenting the documents
Similarities: Both documents deal with the prosperity of New York City, so on a local scale, in the economic capital of the USA, a dvped country.
Differences: The 1st doc is an ad about NYC’s economic power from the webpage ”Why NYC” posted by the NYC Economic Development Corporation on edc.nyc and retrieved on 2 November 2021 whereas the 2nd doc is a report about Safeguarding NYC shore by Scott M. Stringer, NYC Comptroller and published by the Bureau of Policy and Research on May 9, 2019.
Give structure: In a 1st part I’ll focus on NYC global power illustrated by the web page & in a 2nd part I’ll show it is threatened using the report.
Stage 2 - Analysing the documents
DESCRIBING - What you see (docs) |
INTERPRETING - What you know (notions) |
1. A global power with the ad |
|
A global business centre: |
Central business district (def), cluster (def), hub (def), pull factor (def 2E), migration (def) |
2. But a threatened city with the report |
|
P1 The threat: climate change. |
Climate change (def. 2E) and need for energy transition (def 2E) |
Stage 3 - Concluding
Assess docs: To conclude, these documents are reliable as we have their full references ; the ad is biased as it is promoting NYC but the report is unbiased because it just gives the facts..
Sum-up ideas: These docs show that NYC has a global economic power but that it is highly vulnerable to climate change despite its wealth and power.
Open: We may wonder if London, another global city, is as vulnerable to climate change, although it is located on the Thames and not on the coast.